Player Head-to-Head
CS
Collie Smith
WI
VS
SR
Sherfane Rutherford
WI
2 wonStat categorieswon 5

Collie Smith vs Sherfane Rutherford

Collie Smith and Sherfane Rutherford compared across career, Test, ODI and T20I — batting, bowling and season by season.

Final Verdict

Sherfane Rutherford has the edge in overall. In recent years, both have been evenly matched.

CAREER Sherfane RutherfordTEST LevelODI LevelT20I Level
Format

All formats

CS 2 – 5 SR
1331
Most Runs
1324
168
Highest Score
181
0
Best Strike Rate
240
12
Most sixes
70
79
Most Fours
107
6
Most 50s
10
3
Most 100s
1
–
Most Not Outs
9

Season by season

2026

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
347
–
Highest Score
137
–
Best Strike Rate
281
–
Most sixes
23
–
Most Fours
22
–
Most 50s
3
–
Most Not Outs
5

2025

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
406
–
Highest Score
121
–
Best Strike Rate
208
–
Most sixes
16
–
Most Fours
41
–
Most 50s
3

2024

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
715
–
Highest Score
181
–
Best Strike Rate
260
–
Most sixes
43
–
Most Fours
50
–
Most 50s
6
–
Most 100s
1
–
Most Not Outs
9

2023

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
167
–
Highest Score
99
–
Best Strike Rate
248
–
Most sixes
8
–
Most Fours
15
–
Most 50s
1

2020

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
26
–
Highest Score
26
–
Best Strike Rate
200
–
Most sixes
3
–
Most Fours
0

2019

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
15
–
Highest Score
9
–
Best Strike Rate
88
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
1

2018

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
2
–
Highest Score
2
–
Best Strike Rate
33
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
0

1959

CS 0 – 0 SR
186
Most Runs
–
100
Highest Score
–
2
Most sixes
–
2
Most Fours
–

1958

CS 0 – 0 SR
465
Most Runs
–
86
Highest Score
–
3
Most sixes
–
12
Most Fours
–
5
Most 50s
–

1957

CS 0 – 0 SR
396
Most Runs
–
168
Highest Score
–
4
Most sixes
–
37
Most Fours
–
2
Most 100s
–

1956

CS 0 – 0 SR
78
Most Runs
–
64
Highest Score
–
0
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
9
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–

1955

CS 0 – 0 SR
206
Most Runs
–
104
Highest Score
–
0
Best Strike Rate
–
1
Most sixes
–
19
Most Fours
–
1
Most 100s
–

TEST career

CS 0 – 0 SR
1331
Most Runs
–
168
Highest Score
–
0
Best Strike Rate
–
12
Most sixes
–
79
Most Fours
–
6
Most 50s
–
3
Most 100s
–

Season by season

1959

CS 0 – 0 SR
186
Most Runs
–
100
Highest Score
–
2
Most sixes
–
2
Most Fours
–

1958

CS 0 – 0 SR
465
Most Runs
–
86
Highest Score
–
3
Most sixes
–
12
Most Fours
–
5
Most 50s
–

1957

CS 0 – 0 SR
396
Most Runs
–
168
Highest Score
–
4
Most sixes
–
37
Most Fours
–
2
Most 100s
–

1956

CS 0 – 0 SR
78
Most Runs
–
64
Highest Score
–
0
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
9
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–

1955

CS 0 – 0 SR
206
Most Runs
–
104
Highest Score
–
0
Best Strike Rate
–
1
Most sixes
–
19
Most Fours
–
1
Most 100s
–

ODI career

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
736
–
Highest Score
113
–
Best Strike Rate
102
–
Most sixes
35
–
Most Fours
62
–
Most 50s
7
–
Most 100s
1
–
Most Not Outs
3

Season by season

2026

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
101
–
Highest Score
61
–
Best Strike Rate
95
–
Most sixes
6
–
Most Fours
5
–
Most 50s
1
–
Most Not Outs
1

2025

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
246
–
Highest Score
70
–
Best Strike Rate
84
–
Most sixes
10
–
Most Fours
22
–
Most 50s
2

2024

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
425
–
Highest Score
113
–
Best Strike Rate
120
–
Most sixes
23
–
Most Fours
33
–
Most 50s
4
–
Most 100s
1
–
Most Not Outs
3

2023

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
72
–
Highest Score
63
–
Best Strike Rate
78
–
Most sixes
2
–
Most Fours
7
–
Most 50s
1

T20I career

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
588
–
Highest Score
68
–
Best Strike Rate
138
–
Most sixes
35
–
Most Fours
45
–
Most 50s
3
–
Most Not Outs
6

Season by season

2026

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
246
–
Highest Score
76
–
Best Strike Rate
186
–
Most sixes
17
–
Most Fours
17
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most Not Outs
4

2025

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
160
–
Highest Score
51
–
Best Strike Rate
124
–
Most sixes
6
–
Most Fours
19
–
Most 50s
1

2024

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
290
–
Highest Score
68
–
Best Strike Rate
140
–
Most sixes
20
–
Most Fours
17
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most Not Outs
6

2023

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
95
–
Highest Score
36
–
Best Strike Rate
170
–
Most sixes
6
–
Most Fours
8

2020

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
26
–
Highest Score
26
–
Best Strike Rate
200
–
Most sixes
3
–
Most Fours
0

2019

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
15
–
Highest Score
9
–
Best Strike Rate
88
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
1

2018

CS 0 – 0 SR
–
Most Runs
2
–
Highest Score
2
–
Best Strike Rate
33
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
0
RECENT RESULTS 1 match