Former Cricketer's Harsh Critique
As the Ashes 2025-26 series reaches a critical point, Sadagopan Ramesh, a former opener for India, has voiced serious concerns regarding Brendon McCullum's ability as England's red-ball coach. After a dismal performance that has put England at a 0-3 deficit in the series against Australia, Ramesh's comments have sparked debate about the efficacy of McCullum's tactics.
England's Struggles in the Series
The aggressive approach that initially seemed beneficial for England in shorter formats is now being seen as a liability in Test matches. Ramesh pointed out that this strategy was notably ineffective during recent overseas tours, which resulted in disappointing outcomes in both India and Pakistan. Now, with two Tests left to play in Australia, the pressure is mounting.
| Test Match | England's Innings | Aussies' Performance |
|---|
| 1st Test, Perth | 66.9 overs | Travis Head: 100 |
| 2nd Test, Brisbane | Winless | Key Moments Lost |
| 3rd Test, Adelaide | Winless | Key Moments Lost |
In the first Test at Perth, England was all out in just 66.9 overs, allowing Australia to take an early lead. With their loss in the subsequent matches, including tight contests in Brisbane and Adelaide, they have now gone 18 Tests without a win in Australia.
The Coaching Dilemma
Ramesh, in a candid Instagram video, shared his belief that coaches should not impose their personal playing style onto the teams they lead. He emphasized that while McCullum's innovative strategies have attracted attention, they lack the depth needed for Test cricket.
Rahul Dravid's approach as India’s coach provides a contrasting perspective. Ramesh highlighted that Dravid did not enforce a conservative batting style, which allowed the Indian team to thrive, exemplified by their 2022 T20 World Cup triumph.
McCullum's position as coach could become precarious if England finishes this tour without a win. With the fourth Test approaching, changes to the lineup have been made, notably the replacement of Ollie Pope with Jacob Bethell at number three.
Looking Ahead
The upcoming Test on Boxing Day at the Melbourne Cricket Ground will be crucial for England. If the team hopes to salvage their series, adjustments in strategy and performance must be evident. Only time will tell if Ramesh's critique holds weight as England faces the daunting task ahead.