Player Head-to-Head
JB
Jacob Butler
VS
TM
Tony MacGibbon
NZ
3 wonStat categorieswon 10

Jacob Butler vs Tony MacGibbon

Jacob Butler and Tony MacGibbon compared across career, Test, ODI and T20I — batting, bowling and season by season.

Final Verdict

Tony MacGibbon has the edge in overall. In recent years, both have been evenly matched.

CAREER Tony MacGibbonTEST LevelODI LevelT20I Level
Format

All formats

JB 3 – 10 TM
Batting
16
Most Runs
814
8
Highest Score
66
57
Best Strike Rate
0
0
Most sixes
4
0
Most Fours
72
–
Most 50s
3
2
Most Not Outs
5
Bowling
18
Most Wickets
70
15
Best Average
31
10
Most Dots
0
7
Best Economy
2
12
Best Strike Rate
76
277
Most Runs Conceed
2160
0
Most Maiden Overs
228
–
Five Wicket haul
1

Season by season

2026

JB 0 – 0 TM
8
Most Runs
–
8
Highest Score
–
100
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–

2023

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
14
Most Runs
–
8
Highest Score
–
56
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
4
Most Wickets
–
22
Best Average
–
2
Most Dots
–
8
Best Economy
–
15
Best Strike Rate
–
86
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2022

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
2
Most Runs
–
2
Highest Score
–
67
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
5
Most Wickets
–
18
Best Average
–
3
Most Dots
–
8
Best Economy
–
13
Best Strike Rate
–
89
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2021

JB 0 – 0 TM
Bowling
8
Most Wickets
–
9
Best Average
–
2
Most Dots
–
5
Best Economy
–
10
Best Strike Rate
–
68
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2020

JB 0 – 0 TM
Bowling
1
Most Wickets
–
34
Best Average
–
3
Most Dots
–
11
Best Economy
–
18
Best Strike Rate
–
34
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

1958

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
175
–
Highest Score
66
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
18
–
Most 50s
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
20
–
Best Average
19
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Best Strike Rate
53
–
Most Runs Conceed
389
–
Most Maiden Overs
50
–
Five Wicket haul
1

1956

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
148
–
Highest Score
36
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
21
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
10
–
Best Average
32
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
75
–
Most Runs Conceed
319
–
Most Maiden Overs
29

1955

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
359
–
Highest Score
61
–
Best Strike Rate
0
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
29
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most Not Outs
3
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
17
–
Best Average
47
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Best Strike Rate
118
–
Most Runs Conceed
803
–
Most Maiden Overs
95

1954

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
47
–
Highest Score
14
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
12
–
Best Average
22
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
51
–
Most Runs Conceed
258
–
Most Maiden Overs
25

1953

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
53
–
Highest Score
21
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
0
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
11
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
62
–
Most Runs Conceed
285
–
Most Maiden Overs
23

1951

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
32
–
Highest Score
20
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
3
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Most Runs Conceed
106
–
Most Maiden Overs
6

TEST career

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
814
–
Highest Score
66
–
Best Strike Rate
0
–
Most sixes
4
–
Most Fours
72
–
Most 50s
3
–
Most Not Outs
5
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
70
–
Best Average
31
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Best Strike Rate
76
–
Most Runs Conceed
2160
–
Most Maiden Overs
228
–
Five Wicket haul
1

Season by season

2026

JB 0 – 0 TM
4
Most Runs
–
4
Highest Score
–
50
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–

1958

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
175
–
Highest Score
66
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
18
–
Most 50s
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
20
–
Best Average
19
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Best Strike Rate
53
–
Most Runs Conceed
389
–
Most Maiden Overs
50
–
Five Wicket haul
1

1956

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
148
–
Highest Score
36
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
21
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
10
–
Best Average
32
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
75
–
Most Runs Conceed
319
–
Most Maiden Overs
29

1955

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
359
–
Highest Score
61
–
Best Strike Rate
0
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
29
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most Not Outs
3
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
17
–
Best Average
47
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Best Strike Rate
118
–
Most Runs Conceed
803
–
Most Maiden Overs
95

1954

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
47
–
Highest Score
14
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
12
–
Best Average
22
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
51
–
Most Runs Conceed
258
–
Most Maiden Overs
25

1953

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
53
–
Highest Score
21
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
0
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
11
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Best Strike Rate
62
–
Most Runs Conceed
285
–
Most Maiden Overs
23

1951

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
–
Most Runs
32
–
Highest Score
20
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
3
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Most Runs Conceed
106
–
Most Maiden Overs
6

T20I career

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
16
Most Runs
–
8
Highest Score
–
57
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
2
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
18
Most Wickets
–
15
Best Average
–
10
Most Dots
–
7
Best Economy
–
12
Best Strike Rate
–
277
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

Season by season

2026

JB 0 – 0 TM
4
Most Runs
–
4
Highest Score
–
50
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–

2023

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
14
Most Runs
–
8
Highest Score
–
56
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
4
Most Wickets
–
22
Best Average
–
2
Most Dots
–
8
Best Economy
–
15
Best Strike Rate
–
86
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2022

JB 0 – 0 TM
Batting
2
Most Runs
–
2
Highest Score
–
67
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
5
Most Wickets
–
18
Best Average
–
3
Most Dots
–
8
Best Economy
–
13
Best Strike Rate
–
89
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2021

JB 0 – 0 TM
Bowling
8
Most Wickets
–
9
Best Average
–
2
Most Dots
–
5
Best Economy
–
10
Best Strike Rate
–
68
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–

2020

JB 0 – 0 TM
Bowling
1
Most Wickets
–
34
Best Average
–
3
Most Dots
–
11
Best Economy
–
18
Best Strike Rate
–
34
Most Runs Conceed
–
0
Most Maiden Overs
–