Former Australia captain Michael Clarke has reopened one of cricket’s most scrutinised scandals by arguing that the 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering fallout should have been handled as a team-wide issue. Speaking on the Beyond23 Cricket Podcast, Clarke said the response should have reflected collective responsibility rather than leaving Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft to absorb the full weight of the sanctions.
His comments come after renewed discussion around Sandpapergate, sparked by Cameron Bancroft’s claim that the wider Australia squad knew sandpaper was being used during the third Test against South Africa in March 2018. Clarke’s position is not a defence of the act itself. Instead, it is a critique of how accountability, leadership and punishment were distributed after the incident.
What Clarke said about responsibility
Clarke’s core point was that if the team had been united in the decision-making process, then the public response should have reflected that same unity. He said he would have fronted the media alone as captain, taking personal responsibility first, before drawing in the rest of the group if necessary.
That view places emphasis on leadership behaviour rather than only disciplinary outcomes. In Clarke’s framing, the issue was not simply who applied the sandpaper, but how the entire dressing room should have responded once the incident came to light.
Leadership and media response
Clarke also noted that Steve Smith did not walk into the press conference entirely alone, saying Smith brought his coach with him and that he respected that decision. For Clarke, that detail mattered because it showed an attempt to manage the situation within a leadership structure, rather than treating it as an isolated player issue.
| Key Figure | Role in 2018 Incident | Sanction |
|---|
| Steve Smith | Captain | 1-year ban |
| David Warner | Vice-captain | 1-year ban |
| Cameron Bancroft | Player caught tampering | 9-month suspension |
The punishment table remains central to why the scandal still attracts debate. Smith and Bancroft later admitted the act was pre-planned, while Smith said the responsibility sat with the team’s leadership group. Clarke’s latest remarks suggest that, in his view, the consequences should not have stopped at three individuals if the broader squad had knowledge of what was being done.
Why the punishments are being revisited
Clarke said the sanctions felt too severe at the time, although he also made clear that the three players involved still had to face consequences. His argument is more nuanced than a call for exoneration. It is a claim that the punishment framework did not fully match the scale of the alleged team environment around the event.
That nuance matters because the 2018 incident was not only about a match-day offence. It became a leadership crisis, a public trust issue and a long-term reputational stain on Australian cricket. In that sense, Clarke’s comments are also about institutional memory: how governing bodies and teams handle scandals when evidence and responsibility are unevenly distributed.
Bancroft, Khawaja and the revived debate
Clarke also said he understood Bancroft’s frustration, pointing out that the opener did not get much of a chance to return and represent Australia again after the scandal. Bancroft’s international career effectively stalled after the incident, adding another layer to the question of proportional punishment versus long-term damage.
The renewed debate has also been fuelled by Usman Khawaja’s book Sabr, in which he revisited the South Africa series and the wider context around it. A separate Beyond23 episode featuring Damien Martyn has further revived discussion over whether the matter should be examined again.
| Incident | Month/Year | Format |
|---|
| South Africa Test, Cape Town | March 2018 | Third Test |
| Cricket Australia disciplinary action | 2018 | Bans and suspension |
| Renewed public debate | November 2026 | Podcast discussion |
Why the issue still matters eight years later
Clarke said the matter is still difficult because, in his view, the original investigation was not thorough enough. That is a significant claim, especially given how strongly the incident shaped public attitudes toward Australia’s men’s team in the years that followed. It also speaks to a broader question in elite sport: when an incident involves multiple people, how much of the truth is allowed to remain partial before a full inquiry becomes necessary?
Cricket Australia has now announced a forum where players and staff can share their accounts, although the format, date and participants have not yet been confirmed. That step suggests the governing body recognises that the issue remains unresolved in the public sphere, even if the disciplinary outcomes from 2018 are unchanged.
For Clarke, the principle is clear: accountability should be shared when responsibility is shared. His “one in, all in” view is less about rewriting the record and more about questioning whether Australian cricket dealt with the scandal in a way that matched the scale of the event, the leadership structure involved and the long-term consequences that followed.