Player Head-to-Head
SC
Stuart Carlisle
ZIM
VS
MB
Mark Butcher
ENG
19 wonStat categorieswon 20

Stuart Carlisle vs Mark Butcher

Stuart Carlisle and Mark Butcher compared across career, Test, ODI and T20I — batting, bowling and season by season.

Final Verdict

Mark Butcher has the edge in overall and Tests. In recent years, both have been evenly matched.

CAREER Mark ButcherTEST Mark ButcherODI LevelT20I Level
Format

All formats

SC 5 – 3 MB
Batting
4355
Most Runs
4288
239
Highest Score
173
100
Best Strike Rate
43
38
Most sixes
3
394
Most Fours
559
17
Most 50s
23
5
Most 100s
8
14
Most Not Outs
7
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
15
–
Best Average
36
–
Most Dots
6
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
60
–
Most Runs Conceed
541
–
Most Maiden Overs
27

Season by season

2005

SC 0 – 0 MB
95
Most Runs
–
50
Highest Score
–
71
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
7
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

2004

SC 3 – 3 MB
498
Most Runs
498
212
Highest Score
79
122
Best Strike Rate
40
2
Most sixes
0
45
Most Fours
62
2
Most 50s
6
2
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
3

2003

SC 0 – 5 MB
Batting
261
Most Runs
979
118
Highest Score
137
38
Best Strike Rate
47
2
Most sixes
2
34
Most Fours
148
–
Most 50s
5
1
Most 100s
3
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
5
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
1
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
37
–
Most Runs Conceed
129
–
Most Maiden Overs
3

2002

SC 2 – 4 MB
Batting
414
Most Runs
887
117
Highest Score
123
116
Best Strike Rate
45
1
Most sixes
0
37
Most Fours
108
2
Most 50s
5
–
Most 100s
2
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
2
–
Best Average
81
–
Most Dots
2
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
129
–
Most Runs Conceed
161
–
Most Maiden Overs
9

2000

SC 5 – 0 MB
Batting
1026
Most Runs
80
149
Highest Score
40
93
Best Strike Rate
31
7
Most sixes
0
95
Most Fours
13
6
Most 50s
–
2
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Most Runs Conceed
9
–
Most Maiden Overs
0

1999

SC 4 – 1 MB
Batting
374
Most Runs
235
121
Highest Score
48
83
Best Strike Rate
33
12
Most sixes
0
24
Most Fours
30
1
Most 100s
–
3
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
3
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
40
–
Most Runs Conceed
77
–
Most Maiden Overs
2

1998

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
–
Most Runs
684
–
Highest Score
116
–
Best Strike Rate
38
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
80
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most 100s
2
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Most Runs Conceed
69
–
Most Maiden Overs
8

1997

SC 0 – 4 MB
Batting
13
Most Runs
254
6
Highest Score
87
22
Best Strike Rate
41
0
Most sixes
0
0
Most Fours
32
–
Most 50s
2
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
7
–
Most Runs Conceed
14
–
Most Maiden Overs
0

1996

SC 0 – 0 MB
150
Most Runs
–
86
Highest Score
–
91
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
16
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–

1995

SC 0 – 0 MB
91
Most Runs
–
55
Highest Score
–
72
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
6
Most Fours
–
2
Most Not Outs
–

TEST career

SC 1 – 7 MB
Batting
1615
Most Runs
4288
118
Highest Score
173
37
Best Strike Rate
43
10
Most sixes
3
185
Most Fours
559
8
Most 50s
23
2
Most 100s
8
6
Most Not Outs
7
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
15
–
Best Average
36
–
Most Dots
6
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
60
–
Most Runs Conceed
541
–
Most Maiden Overs
27

Season by season

2005

SC 0 – 0 MB
31
Most Runs
–
20
Highest Score
–
28
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
4
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

2004

SC 3 – 4 MB
194
Most Runs
498
103
Highest Score
79
53
Best Strike Rate
40
2
Most sixes
0
18
Most Fours
62
1
Most 50s
6
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
3

2003

SC 0 – 5 MB
Batting
261
Most Runs
979
118
Highest Score
137
38
Best Strike Rate
47
2
Most sixes
2
34
Most Fours
148
–
Most 50s
5
1
Most 100s
3
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
5
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
1
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
37
–
Most Runs Conceed
129
–
Most Maiden Overs
3

2002

SC 1 – 5 MB
Batting
263
Most Runs
887
77
Highest Score
123
34
Best Strike Rate
45
1
Most sixes
0
30
Most Fours
108
2
Most 50s
5
–
Most 100s
2
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
2
–
Best Average
81
–
Most Dots
2
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
129
–
Most Runs Conceed
161
–
Most Maiden Overs
9

2000

SC 5 – 0 MB
Batting
340
Most Runs
80
58
Highest Score
40
37
Best Strike Rate
31
2
Most sixes
0
41
Most Fours
13
2
Most 50s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
3
–
Most Runs Conceed
9
–
Most Maiden Overs
0

1999

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
–
Most Runs
235
–
Highest Score
48
–
Best Strike Rate
33
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
30
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
3
–
Best Average
26
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
4
–
Best Strike Rate
40
–
Most Runs Conceed
77
–
Most Maiden Overs
2

1998

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
–
Most Runs
684
–
Highest Score
116
–
Best Strike Rate
38
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
80
–
Most 50s
2
–
Most 100s
2
–
Most Not Outs
1
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
2
–
Most Runs Conceed
69
–
Most Maiden Overs
8

1997

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
–
Most Runs
254
–
Highest Score
87
–
Best Strike Rate
41
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
32
–
Most 50s
2
Bowling
–
Most Wickets
0
–
Most Dots
0
–
Best Economy
7
–
Most Runs Conceed
14
–
Most Maiden Overs
0

1996

SC 0 – 0 MB
97
Most Runs
–
58
Highest Score
–
36
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
13
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–

1995

SC 0 – 0 MB
78
Most Runs
–
46
Highest Score
–
34
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
6
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

ODI career

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
2740
Most Runs
–
121
Highest Score
–
63
Best Strike Rate
–
28
Most sixes
–
209
Most Fours
–
9
Most 50s
–
3
Most 100s
–
8
Most Not Outs
–

Season by season

2005

SC 0 – 0 MB
64
Most Runs
–
30
Highest Score
–
43
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
3
Most Fours
–

2004

SC 0 – 0 MB
304
Most Runs
–
109
Highest Score
–
69
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
27
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–

2002

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
151
Most Runs
–
40
Highest Score
–
82
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
7
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

2000

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
686
Most Runs
–
91
Highest Score
–
56
Best Strike Rate
–
5
Most sixes
–
54
Most Fours
–
4
Most 50s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1999

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
374
Most Runs
–
121
Highest Score
–
83
Best Strike Rate
–
12
Most sixes
–
24
Most Fours
–
1
Most 100s
–
3
Most Not Outs
–

1997

SC 0 – 0 MB
Batting
13
Most Runs
–
6
Highest Score
–
22
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–

1996

SC 0 – 0 MB
53
Most Runs
–
28
Highest Score
–
55
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
3
Most Fours
–

1995

SC 0 – 0 MB
13
Most Runs
–
9
Highest Score
–
38
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most Not Outs
–
RECENT RESULTS 1 match