Player Head-to-Head
BB
Basil Butcher
WI
VS
CM
Colin McDonald
AUS
9 wonStat categorieswon 11

Basil Butcher vs Colin McDonald

Basil Butcher and Colin McDonald compared across career, Test, ODI and T20I — batting, bowling and season by season.

Final Verdict

Colin McDonald has the edge in overall and Tests. In recent years, both have been evenly matched.

CAREER Colin McDonaldTEST Colin McDonaldODI LevelT20I Level
Format

All formats

BB 6 – 2 CM
3104
Most Runs
3107
209
Highest Score
170
49
Best Strike Rate
44
6
Most sixes
3
266
Most Fours
166
16
Most 50s
17
7
Most 100s
5
6
Most Not Outs
4

Season by season

1969

BB 0 – 0 CM
794
Most Runs
–
118
Highest Score
–
49
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
96
Most Fours
–
5
Most 50s
–
2
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1968

BB 0 – 0 CM
366
Most Runs
–
86
Highest Score
–
51
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
42
Most Fours
–
3
Most 50s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1967

BB 0 – 0 CM
24
Most Runs
–
24
Highest Score
–
0
Most sixes
–
4
Most Fours
–

1966

BB 0 – 0 CM
482
Most Runs
–
209
Highest Score
–
52
Best Strike Rate
–
1
Most sixes
–
57
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1965

BB 0 – 0 CM
405
Most Runs
–
117
Highest Score
–
1
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–

1963

BB 0 – 0 CM
383
Most Runs
–
133
Highest Score
–
42
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
42
Most Fours
–
2
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1961

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
331
–
Highest Score
91
–
Best Strike Rate
41
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
13
–
Most 50s
3

1960

BB 0 – 3 CM
31
Most Runs
186
13
Highest Score
57
–
Best Strike Rate
56
0
Most sixes
0
0
Most Fours
8
–
Most 50s
1

1959

BB 0 – 5 CM
362
Most Runs
671
142
Highest Score
170
–
Best Strike Rate
47
0
Most sixes
0
10
Most Fours
29
2
Most 50s
2
1
Most 100s
2
1
Most Not Outs
2

1958

BB 3 – 1 CM
257
Most Runs
259
103
Highest Score
58
–
Best Strike Rate
35
0
Most sixes
0
15
Most Fours
7
2
Most 50s
1
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
1

1957

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
199
–
Highest Score
99
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
0
–
Most 50s
2

1956

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
295
–
Highest Score
89
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
26
–
Most 50s
2

1955

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
635
–
Highest Score
127
–
Best Strike Rate
50
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
33
–
Most 50s
3
–
Most 100s
2
–
Most Not Outs
1

1953

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
288
–
Highest Score
154
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
26
–
Most 50s
1
–
Most 100s
1

1952

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
243
–
Highest Score
82
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
24
–
Most 50s
2

TEST career

BB 6 – 2 CM
3104
Most Runs
3107
209
Highest Score
170
49
Best Strike Rate
44
6
Most sixes
3
266
Most Fours
166
16
Most 50s
17
7
Most 100s
5
6
Most Not Outs
4

Season by season

1969

BB 0 – 0 CM
794
Most Runs
–
118
Highest Score
–
49
Best Strike Rate
–
0
Most sixes
–
96
Most Fours
–
5
Most 50s
–
2
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1968

BB 0 – 0 CM
366
Most Runs
–
86
Highest Score
–
51
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
42
Most Fours
–
3
Most 50s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1967

BB 0 – 0 CM
24
Most Runs
–
24
Highest Score
–
0
Most sixes
–
4
Most Fours
–

1966

BB 0 – 0 CM
482
Most Runs
–
209
Highest Score
–
52
Best Strike Rate
–
1
Most sixes
–
57
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1965

BB 0 – 0 CM
405
Most Runs
–
117
Highest Score
–
1
Most sixes
–
0
Most Fours
–
1
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–

1963

BB 0 – 0 CM
383
Most Runs
–
133
Highest Score
–
42
Best Strike Rate
–
2
Most sixes
–
42
Most Fours
–
2
Most 50s
–
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
–

1961

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
331
–
Highest Score
91
–
Best Strike Rate
41
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
13
–
Most 50s
3

1960

BB 0 – 3 CM
31
Most Runs
186
13
Highest Score
57
–
Best Strike Rate
56
0
Most sixes
0
0
Most Fours
8
–
Most 50s
1

1959

BB 0 – 5 CM
362
Most Runs
671
142
Highest Score
170
–
Best Strike Rate
47
0
Most sixes
0
10
Most Fours
29
2
Most 50s
2
1
Most 100s
2
1
Most Not Outs
2

1958

BB 3 – 1 CM
257
Most Runs
259
103
Highest Score
58
–
Best Strike Rate
35
0
Most sixes
0
15
Most Fours
7
2
Most 50s
1
1
Most 100s
–
1
Most Not Outs
1

1957

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
199
–
Highest Score
99
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
0
–
Most 50s
2

1956

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
295
–
Highest Score
89
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
26
–
Most 50s
2

1955

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
635
–
Highest Score
127
–
Best Strike Rate
50
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
33
–
Most 50s
3
–
Most 100s
2
–
Most Not Outs
1

1953

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
288
–
Highest Score
154
–
Most sixes
1
–
Most Fours
26
–
Most 50s
1
–
Most 100s
1

1952

BB 0 – 0 CM
–
Most Runs
243
–
Highest Score
82
–
Most sixes
0
–
Most Fours
24
–
Most 50s
2