Gautam Gambhir Faces Criticism After India’s Historic Loss to SA

Published: 27 November 2025

India Suffers Historic Defeat

India's cricketing pride took a severe blow as they succumbed to South Africa, facing their biggest home Test loss ever. The 408-run defeat in Guwahati marks Gautam Gambhir's second clean sweep at home as head coach and has ignited widespread debate regarding the direction of Indian red-ball cricket.

Declining Home Fortress

Since 2000, India treated home Tests as a near-impenetrable fortress. However, this season has seen a dramatic shift, with India losing five out of nine home Tests under Gambhir’s leadership. This record is unprecedented in the last 25 years for any Indian coach.

YearTests PlayedWinsLossesDraws
2000-20239450

The defeat against South Africa raised urgent questions about the overall team strategy and Gambhir's coaching methods. Fans and analysts have expressed shock, noting that India folded within three days, a stark contrast to past performances.

Gambhir's Coaching Record

Gautam Gambhir's current win-loss ratio stands at 0.80, with a win percentage of just 44.4%. Comparatively, his predecessors like Ravi Shastri and Anil Kumble enjoyed outstanding records at home, making Gambhir's situation even more concerning.

“This team looks flat and reactive rather than taking charge,” noted a former player, echoing sentiments of supporters who feel Gambhir needs to recalibrate the team’s approach.

Challenges Ahead

As India prepares for significant international tours, the need for stable team selection and a clear strategy is more pressing than ever. Many fans are advocating for immediate changes to avert further decline.

Need for Patience and Trust

In the light of rising criticism, Gambhir has urged patience, explaining, “Rebuilding takes time, and the team needs to trust the process.” Nevertheless, this statement has failed to calm the discontent among the fans.

With upcoming marquee tours looming, the pressure is mounting on Gambhir and the team, whose recent performances have sparked fear and uncertainty for the future of Indian Test cricket.